What your New York HOA can and can't do under New York law — notice, hearings, fines and liens — with exact statute citations.
New York has no statute written for homeowners' associations as a whole, so which rules apply depends on how your community was created. If you own a condominium unit, the Condominium Act (Real Property Law Article 9-B) applies. We searched all 36 of its sections and the word "fine" appears in none of them: it gives the board no express power to fine and sets no notice, cure or hearing steps, so a condominium fine and its procedure come from your by-laws and rules, which the Act says unit owners must follow strictly. If your association is incorporated under the Not-for-Profit Corporation Law, section 507(a) lets it impose "reasonable fines or other penalties" only if its certificate of incorporation or by-laws authorize them, and it states no notice, hearing or dollar cap. A condominium unit is subject to a lien for unpaid common charges, with 90 days' written notice required before a foreclosure suit, but the text we read does not say whether an unpaid fine counts as a common charge. Records: condominium owners may examine the books at convenient weekday hours; members of an incorporated association have a six-month rule and a court application, and members of an incorporated homeowners association may review invoices and ledgers on request. Small claims go from $3,000 to $10,000 depending on the court. We did not read any New York court decision, so we cannot tell you how far a court defers to a board.
These are your enforceable rights under N.Y. Real Prop. Law Art. 9-B (condominiums); N.Y. Not-for-Profit Corp. Law §507 (incorporated associations) (Condominium Act (Real Property Law Article 9-B) and Not-for-Profit Corporation Law; no HOA act). Each right has a specific statute citation you can use in any dispute letter.
Every right below comes from statute text that we read on October 28, 2026 on the New York State Senate's Open Legislation site (nysenate.gov). We could not open that site from our own systems that day, so we opened each section page in a browser and compared each quoted passage with the page text; every one matched. The pages show a most-recent-revision date for each section, and we used the version shown. We found no statement on the pages about whether the text is official. This page covers Real Property Law Article 9-B (all 36 sections searched; sections 339-e, 339-f, 339-j, 339-v, 339-w, 339-z, 339-aa, 339-kk and 339-ll quoted), sections 335-b, 342, 343, 472 and 473; Not-for-Profit Corporation Law sections 507, 602, 605, 621 and 624; the four small-claims definitions (section 1801 of the City Civil Court Act and of the Uniform City, District and Justice Court Acts); and CPLR sections 213 and 214. No New York court decision was read. We did not read the Business Corporation Law, cooperative law, the General Business Law (including the Attorney General's role over condominium offering plans), foreclosure procedure in the Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law, or any statute on signs. This page states only what the text we read says.
New York has no statute written for homeowners' associations as a whole. Four sets of statute text were read: (1) the Condominium Act, Real Property Law Article 9-B (all 36 sections of Article 9-B were loaded and searched, and §339-e, §339-f, §339-j, §339-v, §339-w, §339-z, §339-aa, §339-kk and §339-ll are quoted); it applies only to property whose owners submit it by "duly executing and recording a declaration" (§339-f(1)). (2) The Not-for-Profit Corporation Law (NPCL), which applies to an association that is incorporated under it (§507, §602, §605, §621, §624); whether a given association is such a corporation was not determined and is shown by its certificate of incorporation. (3) Real Property Law §342 (solar) and §343 (electric vehicle charging), which speak of a "homeowners' association" without defining it in the sections read; §335-b (solar easements) and §473 (private transfer fees). (4) Court rules: the small-claims definitions in the four New York court acts and CPLR §213 and §214. Cooperatives (corporations with proprietary leases) were not read. No New York court decision was read.
N.Y. Real Prop. Law §339-f(1); N.Y. Not-for-Profit Corp. Law §507, §602, §605, §621, §624New York condominiums (Real Property Law Article 9-B): none of the 36 sections of Article 9-B contains the word "fine" or "fines", and none states a notice period, a cure period or a hearing before the board charges a fine. What the Article does say is in §339-j: "Each unit owner shall comply strictly with the by-laws and with rules, regulations, resolutions and decisions adopted pursuant thereto", and a failure to comply "shall be ground for an action to recover sums due, for damages or injunctive relief or both maintainable by the board of managers on behalf of the unit owners or, in a proper case, by an aggrieved unit owner." A flagrant or repeated violator may be required to "give sufficient surety or sureties for his future compliance". The by-laws must provide for the "Method of adopting and of amending administrative rules and regulations governing the details of the operation and use of the common elements" and for "restrictions on and requirements respecting the use and maintenance of the units" (§339-v(1)(h), (i)). So a condominium fine, and any notice or hearing steps, come from the by-laws and rules the board adopted, not from a statute read.
N.Y. Real Prop. Law §339-j; §339-v(1)(h), (i)Associations incorporated under the Not-for-Profit Corporation Law (NPCL §507(a)): "If authorized by its certificate of incorporation or by-laws and subject to any limitations stated therein a corporation may levy initiation fees, dues and assessments on its members, whether or not they are voting members, and may impose reasonable fines or other penalties upon its members for violations of its rules and regulations." So the power to fine exists only if the certificate of incorporation or by-laws authorize it, is subject to any limits they state, and must be "reasonable". The section states no notice, hearing, cure period or dollar cap. Section 507(c) lets the certificate or by-laws provide for enforcing collection of fines, "including provisions for the termination of membership, upon reasonable notice, for non-payment of such fees, dues, assessments, fines or other penalties". Ask the association for the by-law clause that authorizes the fine and for the rule you are said to have broken. Whether your association is incorporated under the NPCL was not determined.
N.Y. Not-for-Profit Corp. Law §507(a), (c)No dollar cap on a fine appears in Real Property Law Article 9-B (no section uses the word "fine") or in NPCL §507(a). The only standard in the text is that fines imposed by an NPCL corporation be "reasonable"; the section does not define that word. No cap was found in the sections read; the by-laws or rules may set a schedule or maximum, and a court decision on what is reasonable was not read.
N.Y. Not-for-Profit Corp. Law §507(a); N.Y. Real Prop. Law Article 9-BCondominium by-laws (Real Property Law §339-v(1)). They "shall provide for at least the following", among other things: methods of calling meetings of unit owners, the quorum and the percentage "necessary to adopt decisions binding on all unit owners" (b); "Operation of the property, payment of the common expenses and determination and collection of the common charges" (f); the "Method of adopting and of amending administrative rules and regulations governing the details of the operation and use of the common elements" (h); "restrictions on and requirements respecting the use and maintenance of the units" designed "to prevent unreasonable interference" (i); and a percentage of unit owners, "but not less than sixty-six and two-thirds per cent in number and common interest except in the case where all units are non-residential", that may modify or amend the by-laws (j). The board "may, in its sole discretion, determine that the meeting be held solely or partially by means of electronic communication". The section does not say what happens if the board skips its own by-law steps.
N.Y. Real Prop. Law §339-v(1)Condominium lien (Real Property Law §339-z, §339-aa). The board "shall have a lien on each unit for the unpaid common charges thereof, together with interest thereon, prior to all other liens except only" tax liens, "all sums unpaid on a first mortgage of record" and certain subordinate government-agency mortgages (§339-z). "Common charges" means "each unit's proportionate share of the common expenses in accordance with its common interest" (§339-e(2)), and "Common expenses" includes expenses of operation and "All sums designated common expenses by or pursuant to the provisions of this article, the declaration or the by-laws" (§339-e(4)). The sections read do not say whether an unpaid fine is a common charge or a common expense, and no section of the Article uses the word "fine". The lien is effective on filing a "verified notice of lien" stating the owner, the unit, "the amount and purpose for which due, and the date when due", and continues "until expiration six years from the date of filing, whichever occurs sooner" (§339-aa). The lien "may be foreclosed by suit ... in like manner as a mortgage of real property". Before suing the board "shall be required to provide notice to the unit owner at least ninety days prior to the commencement of a foreclosure proceeding", in "fourteen-point type", stating the address and "the specific amount due". The owner must pay "a reasonable rental for the unit" before the sale "if so provided in the by-laws", and the plaintiff may have a receiver appointed. A suit for a money judgment "shall be maintainable without foreclosing or waiving the lien". A grantor or grantee of a unit is "entitled to a statement from the manager or board of managers" of the unpaid common charges (§339-z).
N.Y. Real Prop. Law §339-e(2), (4); §339-z; §339-aaCondominium rent collection (Real Property Law §339-kk). If a non-occupying owner rents a unit and fails to pay "common charges, assessments or late fees" "within sixty days of the expiration of any grace period", then on written notice to the tenant and owner the rent is "directly payable to the condominium association". Where a majority of the board was elected by and from occupying owners, the board "may elect not to require" this. A non-occupying owner who disputes the claim may present facts "at the next scheduled meeting of the board of managers, which must be held within thirty days" of the board receiving notice of the dispute. A tenant's payment to the association "shall be an absolute defense" in a non-payment proceeding by the owner. The text does not name fines.
N.Y. Real Prop. Law §339-kkCondominium sale (Real Property Law §339-z): any grantor or grantee of a unit "shall be entitled to a statement from the manager or board of managers, setting forth the amount of the unpaid common charges accrued against the unit", and neither is liable for, nor is the unit subject to a lien for, unpaid common charges accrued before the conveyance "in excess of the amount therein set forth." The section states no number of days.
N.Y. Real Prop. Law §339-zCondominium records (Real Property Law §339-w). The manager or board "shall keep detailed, accurate records, in chronological order, of the receipts and expenditures arising from the operation of the property"; the records and the vouchers authorizing payments "shall be available for examination by the unit owners at convenient hours of weekdays", and a written summary report must be given to all unit owners "at least once annually". The section states no number of days for a response and no remedy.
N.Y. Real Prop. Law §339-wAssociations incorporated under the Not-for-Profit Corporation Law (§621). The corporation must keep "correct and complete books and records of account and minutes of the proceedings of its members, board and executive committee, if any" and a list of members (a). A person who has been a member of record "for at least six months" may, "upon at least five days written demand", examine the minutes of the members' proceedings and the list of members (b). If the corporation refuses, the person "may apply to the supreme court in the judicial district where the office of the corporation is located" for an order (d). After six months as a member, a written request entitles the member to an annual balance sheet and profit and loss statement (e). Section 621(e-1) adds: "members of a homeowners association incorporated pursuant to the provisions of this chapter shall also be entitled to review, upon request to the homeowners association's governing board, invoices, ledgers, bank accounts, reconciliations, contracts, and any documents related to the expenditure of homeowners association dues." The books and records are "prima facie evidence" in an action against the corporation (g). Paragraph (e-1) states no number of days.
N.Y. Not-for-Profit Corp. Law §621(a), (b), (d), (e), (e-1), (g)Associations incorporated under the Not-for-Profit Corporation Law (§605(a)). Written notice of a members' meeting must state the place, date and hour, the means of electronic participation if any, and, for a special meeting, the purpose. Given personally, by first class mail, by facsimile or by electronic mail, it must be given "not less than ten nor more than fifty days before the date of the meeting"; mailed by any other class, "not less than thirty nor more than sixty days before such date". The page prints two versions of §605; the first is a temporary version tied to a 2020 state disaster emergency and a December 31, 2021 date, and the second, used here, has no such reference. This section concerns members' meetings, not board meetings or fines.
N.Y. Not-for-Profit Corp. Law §605(a)Associations incorporated under the Not-for-Profit Corporation Law. By-laws "may contain any provision relating to the business of the corporation, the conduct of its affairs, its rights or powers or the rights or powers of its members, directors or officers, not inconsistent with this chapter or any other statute of this state or the certificate of incorporation" (§602(f)). For a residential corporation, changes made by the board to the by-laws "shall be provided to the members, stockholders, and delegates of such corporation in writing, by physical or electronic means, within ten days of such adoption" (§602(g)), and where a change "would have a direct effect on the resident's occupancy or the rules of the building" the board must post the by-laws conspicuously so tenants know (§624). Section 602(g) does not define a residential not-for-profit corporation and does not say what follows if the ten days are missed.
N.Y. Not-for-Profit Corp. Law §602(f), (g); §624Private transfer fees (Real Property Law §473): a private transfer fee obligation recorded or entered into on or after the effective date of the section "does not run with the land" and "is void and unenforceable". Section 472(2)(g) lists among amounts that are not private transfer fees any fee, charge, assessment, fine or other amount payable to a homeowners', condominium, cooperative or property owners' association under a declaration, covenant, duly adopted by-law, proprietary lease or law applicable to the association, including fees for estoppel letters or certificates. The effective date of §473 and the rest of Article 15 were not read.
N.Y. Real Prop. Law §473; §472(2)(g)A "small claim" is a cause of action for money only up to a limit that depends on the court: not in excess of ten thousand dollars, exclusive of interest and costs, in the New York City Civil Court (City Civil Court Act §1801); five thousand dollars in a city court (Uniform City Court Act §1801) and in a district court (Uniform District Court Act §1801); three thousand dollars in a town or village justice court (Uniform Justice Court Act §1801). Each section also limits where the defendant must live, work or do business (for example, within the city of New York for the Civil Court, within the county for a city court). Procedure, filing fees and whether a lawyer may appear were not read.
N.Y. City Civil Court Act §1801; Uniform City Court Act §1801; Uniform District Court Act §1801; Uniform Justice Court Act §1801CPLR §213: actions "must be commenced within six years", including "an action for which no limitation is specifically prescribed by law" (1) and "an action upon a contractual obligation or liability, express or implied" (2). CPLR §214: "within three years" for "an action to recover upon a liability, penalty or forfeiture created or imposed by statute except as provided in sections 213 and 215" (2). Which period governs a claim by an association for an unpaid charge or fine, or an owner's claim against an association, was not determined; other limitation sections were not read.
N.Y. CPLR §213(1), (2); §214(2)Remedies stated in the sections read: (1) condominium unit owners: an action for damages or injunctive relief by "an aggrieved unit owner" against a unit owner who fails to comply with the by-laws and rules, and by the board (Real Property Law §339-j); (2) electric vehicle charging: actual damages, a civil penalty up to $1,000 (condominiums) and reasonable attorney's fees to a prevailing owner (§339-ll(i), (j); §343(6)); (3) not-for-profit corporation members: an application to the supreme court for an order permitting inspection of members' minutes and the list of members (NPCL §621(d)). No sentence read states a remedy for a fine imposed in violation of the by-laws. New York decisions on this were not read.
N.Y. Real Prop. Law §339-j; §339-ll(i), (j); §343(6); N.Y. Not-for-Profit Corp. Law §621(d)No New York agency in the sections read has authority to review or void an association's fine. The Attorney General's role over condominium offering plans (General Business Law) was not read.
Sections read; see the note aboveThese activities are protected by New York state law. Any HOA rule or fine that prohibits these things is unenforceable.
This is the required process under New York law. If your HOA skipped any step, the fine may be procedurally defective. Steps marked ⚠️ are the ones HOAs most commonly skip.
The most common questions New York homeowners ask about their HOA rights.
No New York statute we read says so. The Condominium Act has no fine provision and sets no notice or hearing, and the Not-for-Profit Corporation Law fine section (§507(a)) states no notice, hearing or cure period. Any notice or hearing right comes from your by-laws, rules and certificate of incorporation, so read them and compare them with what you received. We did not read any court decision on this.
We found no dollar cap. The only standard in the text we read is that an incorporated association's fines be "reasonable", and the section does not define that word. If your by-laws or rules set a schedule or maximum, the board is bound by it. We did not read any court decision on what is reasonable.
If you own a condominium unit, the board has a lien for "the unpaid common charges" of the unit (§339-z). The sections we read do not say whether an unpaid fine is a common charge, though "common expenses" includes "All sums designated common expenses by or pursuant to the provisions of this article, the declaration or the by-laws" (§339-e(4)). The board must give at least ninety days' written notice before a foreclosure suit (§339-aa). For a house in a planned community we read no lien statute, so whether a fine can become a lien there was not determined.
Condominium owners may examine the books of receipts and expenditures "at convenient hours of weekdays" (§339-w), with no stated response time. Members of an association incorporated under the Not-for-Profit Corporation Law may demand the minutes and the member list in writing (five days, after six months as a member) and apply to the supreme court if refused (§621(b), (d)); members of an incorporated homeowners association may also ask for invoices, ledgers, bank accounts and expenditure documents (§621(e-1)), which states no deadline.
Only within limits. A homeowners' association "may not adopt or enforce any rules or regulations that would effectively prohibit, or impose unreasonable limitations on" a rooftop solar system of up to 25 kW or an electric vehicle charging station (§342, §343), though it may still prohibit a system on property it or its members own in common. A denial must give the specific reasons in writing, and a charging application not denied in writing within sixty days is deemed approved. For a condominium, §339-ll covers charging stations. The sections we read do not define "homeowners' association" or say whether §342 reaches a condominium.
Get your violation score, find procedural errors under New York law, and generate a professional dispute letter citing the exact statutes that apply to your case.
Analyze My Violation — Free →